Visualising success has always struck me as a bit naff. It’s the kind of phrase that belongs on a motivational poster, somewhere between a sunrise and an eagle, and I’m fairly sure those posters are still being printed by the thousand.
And yet I do it. Most days I catch myself picturing a shop. A proper one, on a proper high street, with a rail of clothes on one side and the barber’s chair on the other and a bell above the door that actually rings. I’m not claiming it’s around the corner. It’s just a picture that turns up while I’m doing something else, and lately I’ve started to wonder whether it’s doing me any good, or whether I’m daydreaming my way past the work.
So I went looking, and what I found was a bit of a cold shower.
A psychologist called Gabriele Oettingen spent years studying exactly this. In some of her studies, people who spent their time vividly imagining things going well put in less effort and did worse than people who didn’t. The explanation, as I understand it, is that the brain gets a small taste of the reward just from imagining it, and relaxes. The daydream feels like progress, so the actual work starts to feel less urgent.
That doesn’t make the picture useless. It means the picture on its own isn’t enough. What seemed to work was a second step. Imagine the goal, then picture, just as honestly, what is going to get in the way. Researchers call it mental contrasting, and there’s a tidy four step version with the name WOOP, which stands for wish, outcome, obstacle, plan.
I couldn’t help smiling when I read that, because the Stoics were doing a version of it two thousand years ago. They had a practice called premeditatio malorum, which is a grand way of saying think ahead about what could go wrong. Marcus Aurelius wrote in his notebook that he should begin each morning by reminding himself he’d meet difficult and ungrateful people that day. Not to be gloomy, but so that nothing caught him flat. Positive vision and Stoic realism turn out to be two halves of the same idea.
Here’s how it works in practice, in my own words. Say you want to get fitter. Picture the good bit first, properly, in detail. How you’d feel at the top of the hill, what you’d be wearing, how the morning would look. Then turn to the obstacle, and be honest about it. It’s rarely a lack of willpower. It’s a dark morning, a cold bedroom and a very comfortable bed. Then make a plan that’s as dull as it is specific, an if and then. If the alarm goes at six and it’s dark, then my kit is already by the door and I’m out in ten minutes without making a single decision.
Mine works the same way. The picture is the shop. The obstacles are the obvious ones, money, quiet weeks and days when nobody comes through the door. The plan is the unglamorous part. If it’s been a quiet week, then I do one extra thing to get seen before the week is out, instead of waiting for a better one.
There’s a catch, and it’s the common sense bit. The same research suggests this works best when the goal is realistic. If the wish is so big it’s out of reach, the contrast just leaves you feeling flat, and it’s sensible to aim at something nearer. I’d rather call that honest than defeatist. Pick the version of the dream that sits one or two steps from where you’re standing, and do this for that.
It takes about five minutes, and I’d do it on paper, because things written down are harder to wriggle out of. Wish, picture, obstacle, plan. Nothing mystical about it, and no eagles.
The weather will come, as the Stoics knew. The picture tells you where you’re heading, and the plan for the weather keeps you going when it rains. I’d rather set off for the mountain with a coat on than stay home admiring the postcard.
If you’d like to read more, Time magazine has a clear piece on Oettingen’s work: https://time.com/3503033/from-dreaming-to-doing-steps-to-motivation/

Leave a Reply