Everyone has advice for a small business, and almost all of it is well meant. Lately nearly all of it has pointed the same way. Compete on price. Compete on experience. Compete on how long you’ve been going. I nod, say “I’ll look into that”, and file it away somewhere I won’t trip over it. The advice isn’t wrong, exactly. It’s just that following it means spending a lot of time looking over my shoulder.
This week I’ve been listening to Do It Today by Darius Foroux, on the road and on breaks. His delivery is relentless, a bit gruff, like a man hammering the same nail until it goes in, and I mean that as a compliment. Partway through the chapter on believing you can achieve what you set out to, he mentioned a philosophy of create, don’t compete. Then he moved on. I didn’t. Those three words rode round in my head for the rest of the day.
Here’s where I think they took me.
The idea that we have to compete is so ingrained that most of us never question it. If a company already holds a share of the market, the conventional advice goes, you fight them for a slice of it. And that’s fine as far as it goes. But look at what it does. It hands someone else the rulebook. You’re playing on their pitch, at their price, measured against their years. And on every one of those measures there is always someone better placed. Somebody cheaper. Somebody who started before you were born. You can run as hard as you like, but it’s their race.
Creating asks a different question. Not “how do I beat him?” but “what could I make that nobody else would think to make?” The first question keeps your eyes on other people. The second one puts them back on your own work.
I’ve spent a good many years behind a barber’s chair, and the customers who stay are rarely the ones who found the cheapest cut in town. They stay because of the way they’re looked after, and the chat, and the fact that it’s you. I suspect clothes work the same way. A man who buys a jumper because it was a few pounds cheaper will buy the next one on the same basis. A man who buys it because he likes what it stands for has a reason to come back. Nobody can undercut that, and nobody can out-experience it either, because it isn’t on the same scale.
I’m not saying ignore the market. It’s sensible to know what others charge, and to check you’re not miles out. I’d just rather that wasn’t the whole plan. And I can’t promise that creating pays the bills any faster than competing does. I’m still finding that out.
The Stoics help a little here, as they often do. As I understand it, Epictetus split the world into what’s up to us and what isn’t. A rival’s prices aren’t up to me. What I design next is. That seems a better use of a Tuesday.
If you’d like to try it, here’s a small exercise, and it takes about five minutes. Write down three things you make or do that people can’t easily get anywhere else. Not because they’re better, just because they’re yours. For me it’s the ideas behind the designs, which start with me before the professionals make them real, and this blog, which is written by me and nobody else. Then, next week, put your effort into those, rather than reacting to what someone else is doing.
Next time somebody tells me to compete, I’ll thank them, because they mean well. Then I’ll get back to the one job nobody else can do for me, which is deciding what to make next. Let the rest argue over who’s cheapest. I’d rather build something people choose on purpose.

Leave a Reply